I don't know what to make of the post by Melissa Cole today. At the end she indicates that she has not yet indicated that some of her writing fails to indicate clearly that there may be a conflict of interest... and promises to sort that out. At the beginning she says some others - bloggers no less - may be doing something very bad indeed, perhaps even worse:
...it's come to my attention that some of my fellow beer bloggers are demanding cash for posts and then passing them off as personal opinion, comment or recommendation and I'm just not cool with that.
First, I raise this not to question the idea Melissa raises. While one writer not being cool with something does not an ethical standard make, it is wrong to demand cash for posts unless you have no sense of self respect. Because, while I'd say it still makes for a personal opinion, whether it is a worthwhile one is entirely different matter. Someone outs you and everyone gets to point and make fun. Of you. And no one pays money to an outed fool.
Fine. Ethical point made. My real interest is a second aspect - what bloggers demand cash for posts and then actually get paid? On the one hand, I would like to study the technique and apply it but, on the other, I am stunned that any brewer or festival organizer would buckle and send a check to a blogger. You would have to be a blogger of a certain prominence in terms of readership and, frankly, I just don't see anyone putting out obviously bought content. Here is Pete Brown's recent post on the UK and Ireland's most popular beer bloggers and I just don't see them putting out stories for hire. And please don't tell me money is being wasted on bloggers no one reads. That would be tragic.
All that being said, let me make a last point. I do take money. Because it is lovely and pays for the beer. I take money for ads - including discrete text ads. And for a few sponsored posts that mention the sponsorship, sadly none of late. And for doing whatever else you will pay me for that I don't mind. Profit is, in fact, loverly. I pay taxes on it that goes to build roads and subsidizes nationalized health care. You could give me money, too. If you want to reach those beer nerds who viewed these pages 55,492 times monthly as well as the daily 4,353 Google readers and via a bunch of other stuff, money will do the trick to get your message across. Send me an email.






Comments
Ben - September 16, 2009 10:22 PM
Just short of 4,500 daily readers. Pretty damn impressive.
Ben
Alan - September 16, 2009 11:01 PM
It's not about me. It's about you.
Alan - September 17, 2009 8:28 AM
And a great comparison is when the paying media go out and hunt out content but keep their wallets shut.
Knut Albert Solem - September 17, 2009 11:05 AM
Some us will blog for a pint. Just one step up from street beggars.
Scott @TheBrewClub - September 17, 2009 11:48 AM
Nothing wrong with making money, especially if its from something you really enjoy doing.
Making money by drinking and writing about beer is a very nice idea, and I sure wish I could pull it off somehow! I think readers appreciate the honesty though.
Alan - September 17, 2009 12:43 PM
Knut: GOLD!!!
I do think it is important to realize we are discussing a pop culture commodity that is a medium of pleasure. But it is also a commodity of high value both macro-economically as well as, recently, for the individual bottle. Those who write and think about it deserve their share, too.
Tim - September 17, 2009 4:31 PM
We will blog for beer. Or bacon. mmmmm bacon... Anyone ethically challenged by beer they receive can forward it to me for safe keeping / disposal.
doh... posted twice. sorry Alan.
Alan - September 17, 2009 5:52 PM
No problem - fixed.
And there really should be "A Good Bacon Blog" shouldn't there.
Bailey - October 13, 2009 5:55 PM
I second "Mmmm. Bacon" and heartily endorse this post from a year or two ago over at Brewvana..