No. Not me. It's John Filson. But it is nice to see that someone in the Canadian media has realized that a beer columnist is a good idea for a daily paper. He has only had the gig for three months it seems but his style is good. Consider the following from a column from last November 23rd:
So if you stroll through the LCBO and spot a bottle of Monty Python Holy Grail Ale (it's in the 500-millilitre bottle for $3.25 and made by British brewer Black Sheep) then you're forgiven if you really, really, really want it to be good. Instead, it's like the end of The Meaning of Life, when you've been laughing steadily and just know the final segment is going to be great and this movie is going to be the best ... and then you sit through a literally lifeless sketch in which Death crashes a dinner party. In a weaker movie, it could've been the funniest bit. But in The Meaning of Life, the earlier "Better get a bucket" restaurant-sketch giggles overwhelm the dinner-scene gems like "But I didn't even eat the mousse."Good to see someone is ready to say when a beer is boring. And that one is boring. So good for the Toronto Star. Time for others to pick up the torch especially given all the things that beer is bigger than.The standard was set too high. And when a beer is an homage to the greatest comedy team of all time, you expect a lively, flavourful gem of a beer. Instead, the beer is only okay - an ugly reddish-brown ale, a little thin, a weak bitter aftertaste. If it had been called something generic like Red's Gold's Bitter, then it'd be a forgettable but not annoying beer. Invoke the Python party, though, and it's a failure.






Comments
Greg Clow - January 19, 2006 10:30 AM
Filson has actually been writing about beer in the Star for more than three months. It just that the website only seems to archive stuff that far back.
Alan - January 19, 2006 5:24 PM
Ahhh! What is the benefit of the Star doing that I wonder?
Greg Clow - January 20, 2006 1:05 AM
Limiting the archive, you mean? I dunno. I think that they charge a fee for accessing older news articles, but I can't imagine they would bother to do so for entertainment & lifestyle columns.
Lars Marius Garshol - January 20, 2006 4:48 PM
Really great news that The Toronto Star is doing this! And, yes, if the columnist says a beer is boring s/he must be on to something.
Makes me wonder, though, what possesses chains like LCBO and the Finnish Alko to choose the Monty Python beer from the Black Sheep range. The Riggwelter and the Black Sheep Ale are just fantastic beers, while the MP is (as you say) boring. Maybe Black Sheep should just quietly start putting Black Sheep Ale in those bottles instead? People who buy it for the label get a better beer, and people who want good beer get a better beer. Hard to see how anyone would lose, really.